Skip to main content
Blog
Understanding who is at fault in a truck accident in Tampa and how to prove it is one of the most critical steps victims need to take to recover just compensation.
At The Morgan Law Group, our Tampa truck accident attorneys represent individuals who’ve been seriously injured (or who’ve lost loved ones) in truck collisions – including injured truck drivers who are wrongfully blamed or left without support.
Have a better understanding of what “fault” means in a truck accident, how it’s determined, and how victims can use evidence to support their claims and hold the right parties accountable.
What It Means to Be At Fault in a Truck Accident in Tampa
In legal terms, being “at fault” in a truck accident means being responsible for causing the collision, either through negligent actions or failure to follow traffic and safety regulations. Fault plays a major role in determining who is legally liable, or financially responsible, for the damages sustained.
Because of the scale and danger of truck crashes in Florida, fault is often contested. Trucking companies and insurers move quickly to protect their own interests, which can make it difficult for injured victims to know where to turn.
That’s where a truck accident attorney in Tampa becomes a reliable advocate, ensuring your truck accident claim is built on solid evidence and legal support.
How Many Can Be At Fault in a Truck Accident
Unlike standard car and motorcycle crashes, truck accidents often involve multiple parties, each with a role in the operation and oversight of the truck.
It’s not unusual for more than one party to be partially or fully responsible for a collision. Florida follows the principle of comparative negligence, meaning each at-fault party – including the victim – can be assigned a percentage of fault. This directly affects how damages are awarded.
Here’s a list of who may be at fault in a truck accident, and why:
The Truck Driver
Why they may be at fault:
- Driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol
- Distracted driving (e.g., using a cellphone)
- Speeding or violating traffic laws
- Failing to take required breaks, leading to driver fatigue
- Improper lane changes or failure to yield
Truck drivers are held to higher standards than ordinary drivers due to their commercial licenses and the weight of the vehicles they operate. Even minor negligence can have severe consequences when operating an 80,000-pound truck.
The Trucking Company
Why the trucking company may be at fault:
- Forcing drivers to meet unrealistic schedules
- Failure to perform background checks or provide proper training
- Negligent hiring or retention of unsafe drivers
- Poor supervision or failure to enforce safety standards
- Ignoring known maintenance issues
Trucking companies are responsible for ensuring their drivers are qualified and their vehicles are safe. If they cut corners to boost profits, they can be held liable.
The Truck Owner (if different from the company)
Why they may be at fault:
- Failing to maintain the vehicle according to safety standards
- Ignoring worn brakes, bald tires, or steering issues
- Allowing the truck to be used despite known mechanical problems
In some cases, the truck is owned by a third-party company or contractor. They may share responsibility if the vehicle was in an unsafe condition.
Cargo Loaders or Shipping Companies
Why they may be at fault:
- Overloading the trailer
- Improperly securing the cargo
- Failing to balance the load properly
Improperly loaded cargo can cause rollovers, jackknife accidents, or cause the driver to lose control.
Truck or Parts Manufacturers
Why they may be at fault:
- Producing defective brakes, tires, or steering systems
- Failing to issue recalls for known dangers
- Providing faulty safety equipment
If a mechanical failure causes or contributes to the crash, the manufacturer could be held liable under product liability laws.
Government Entities or Contractors
Why they may be at fault:
- Poorly maintained roads or highways
- Lack of signage or guardrails
- Dangerous construction zones
While rarer, government negligence in maintaining safe roadways can also play a role in truck accidents.
Who Determines Fault in a Truck Accident
Initially, Tampa police and insurance companies will conduct their own investigations to determine truck accident fault. However, in investigations conducted by insurers, it may be unfair.
Ultimately, fault is formally determined by courts. If a lawsuit is filed and proceeds to trial, the court or jury decides who is at fault and what damages are owed.
Because trucking companies and insurers invest heavily in minimizing their liability, having a seasoned accident lawyer in Tampa on your side can make a difference in how fault is assessed and how much compensation is ultimately secured.
How to Prove Who’s at Fault in Truck Crashes
Proving fault in a truck accident requires a methodical, evidence-based approach. Each party will attempt to tell their version of the story, so your legal team must gather, preserve, and present compelling evidence.
A solid truck accident fault claim typically involves:
- Police Reports: These often include initial fault assessments and traffic citations.
- Witness Statements: Eyewitnesses can confirm what they saw during or just before the crash.
- Crash Scene Documentation: Skid marks, debris location, and road conditions may be documented.
- Photographs or Video Footage: Dashcams, security footage, or cell phone videos can show how the crash occurred.
- Electronic Logging Devices (ELDs): These track hours of service, speed, and driving patterns.
- Black Box Data: Commercial trucks often include event data recorders that provide critical insights.
- Maintenance Records: These can show whether the truck was properly serviced.
- Driver Logs and Drug Test Results: These may highlight fatigue, intoxication, or driving violations.
- Expert Analysis: Accident reconstruction specialists can simulate what happened based on evidence.
Evidence serves as the foundation for any injury claim, especially when multiple parties are pointing fingers. The sooner evidence is gathered after the crash, the more reliable and intact it will be.
A truck accident attorney in Tampa can help subpoena records, analyze data, and coordinate with experts to create a full picture of what caused the crash and who is responsible.
Can You Claim for Damages if the Accident Was Your Fault?
Florida’s modified comparative fault rule allows you to recover damages as long as you’re not more than 50% at fault. However, your total compensation will be reduced based on your percentage of fault.
For example:
- If you were found 20% at fault and your total damages were $500,000, you could still recover $400,000.
- But if you were 60% at fault, you may not be able to recover anything under the current Florida law.
This system underscores the importance of proving fault in a truck accident as accurately as possible. Insurance adjusters may try to shift blame to reduce payouts, and without strong legal support, you may receive far less than what you’re truly owed.
We Can Help You Prove Fault in a Truck Accident
Truck accident claims in Tampa are not just about pointing fingers; they’re about holding the right people accountable and helping injured individuals rebuild their lives.
Whether you’re a motorist injured by a careless truck driver or a truck driver wrongfully blamed for a crash, the road to justice begins with clear evidence, experienced guidance, and a strong case for fault.
At The Morgan Law Group, we represent the injured – not the insurance companies. If you or someone you love was hurt in a truck accident, a seasoned attorney in Tampa can help you uncover the truth, determine liability, and fight for full compensation.
Take control of your recovery with the right legal support by your side. Call our office in Tampa today at (813) 590-1779 or contact us using our online form for a free consultation.
